Difference between revisions of "Work Product for Review"

From QIBA Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(120 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
==<font color=red> Public Comment on QIBA Profiles </font>==
+
[[Image:QIBA_WIKI_BLURB.jpg|600px]]
  
 +
<font color="red">NOTICE: These instructions are accessible on the QIBA Wiki as a historical reference only! Independent Profile Authoring Groups are required to oversee the various developmental stages from Draft to Public Comment to Consensus based on the current QUIC endorsement criteria, found HERE:</font> https://qibawiki.rsna.org/images/9/95/QUIC-Review-Criteria-for-New-Profiles-FINAL-v23SEPT2023.pdf.
  
All QIBA technical documents (Profiles, Protocols) are posted for Public Comment to ensure stakeholder representation, transparency and quality review.  All documents are posted via the QIBA WIKI and announced to a broad e-mail distribution list.  QIBA Profiles are posted for public review for a minimum of 30 days before being considered finalized for trial implementation.
 
  
 +
QIBA '''[[Profiles|Profile documents]]''' are posted for '''[[Public Comment Process|Public Comment]]''' to ensure stakeholder representation, transparency and quality review. Interested people are encouraged to provide input on the document, the scenarios and use cases they address, the technologies proposed and other details. 
  
The Public Comment Phase of the development of each QIBA Profile allows interested people to provide input on the Profiles, the scenarios and use cases they address, the technologies proposed and other details.  In particular, vendors who will implement the Profiles and members of the healthcare community who will use the Profiles are encouraged to review and comment.
+
==Comment Submission==
  
*Review the documents listed in the Public Comment WIKI page
+
* ** provide a link to a public comment form (Google forms are recommended for ease of data capture) - ''see example'': [[Image:public comment form.jpg |1200px]]
*Note the deadline listed under the document link
+
:* Select the document you are commenting on from the appropriate form
*Submit your comments via the comment form or direct e-mail to ([mailto:jkoudelik@rsna.org Joe Koudelik])
+
:* Provide your name and email address
 +
:* Add the Profile section and line number (if applicable) to which your comment refers
 +
:* Describe the issue and your propose a resolution
 +
:* When you have entered each of your comments, you may submit the form
 +
* e-mail Profile Authoring Group with ''general comments'' about the Profile/Protocol concept, structure, process, etc.
  
 +
The [[Committees|QIBA Biomarker Committees]] consider all comments submitted, and where appropriate, post responses.
  
The QIBA Technical Committees who develop QIBA Profiles will consider comments submitted in the specified public comment period, and where appropriate, respond to comments.  Please see below for more detailed instructions for submitting comments.
+
==Public Comment Documents==
  
==<font color=red> Directions for Comment Submission </font>==
+
see http://qibawiki.rsna.org/index.php/Profiles
  
Use the form below to submit comments concerning QIBA Profiles to the QIBA Technical Committees.  Documents currently in the Public Comment phase are listed below. Submitted comments will be considered for the revised versions of these Profiles.
 
  
Please enter your comments using the downloadable form below and send by e-mail attachment to ([mailto:jkoudelik@rsna.org Joe Koudelik])
+
*[[Document Archive]]
 
 
*[[Media:FORM QIBA Public Comment.doc|Public Comment Form]]
 
**Comments may also be submitted directly to ([mailto:jkoudelik@rsna.org Joe Koudelik])
 
***Please be sure to include Profile (1) '''title''', (2) '''section''' and (3) '''line numbers''' for reference.
 
 
 
 
 
'''<big><font color=red> Instructions: </font></big>'''
 
 
 
1. Select and download Profiles for review.
 
*[[Media:DCEMRIProfile v1.0 28JUN2011.doc|Profile: <big> DCE-MRI Quantification Version 1.0 </big>]] ''...Public Comment open 11 July 2011 - 11 August 2011''
 
 
 
2. Designate '''Profile Title''', '''Section''' and '''Line Number''' for each comment (or designate as "general"). 
 
 
 
3. Specify the '''Issue''' concisely and provide any new or replacement text in the '''Proposal''' section.
 
 
 
4. Designate the '''Priority''' of each comment as High (H), Medium (M), or Low (L)
 
*  H:  Important issue where there is major issue to be resolved; requires discussion and debate.
 
*  M:  Medium issue or clarification.  Requires discussion, but should not lead to long debate.
 
*  L:  Typo or other minor classification that an editor can manage; requires no group discussion.
 
 
 
5.  After completing form, save it and send as an e-mail attachment to ([mailto:jkoudelik@rsna.org Joe Koudelik]
 
 
 
6. Comments are due by date listed next to each Profile.
 

Latest revision as of 16:56, 19 January 2024

QIBA WIKI BLURB.jpg

NOTICE: These instructions are accessible on the QIBA Wiki as a historical reference only! Independent Profile Authoring Groups are required to oversee the various developmental stages from Draft to Public Comment to Consensus based on the current QUIC endorsement criteria, found HERE: https://qibawiki.rsna.org/images/9/95/QUIC-Review-Criteria-for-New-Profiles-FINAL-v23SEPT2023.pdf.


QIBA Profile documents are posted for Public Comment to ensure stakeholder representation, transparency and quality review. Interested people are encouraged to provide input on the document, the scenarios and use cases they address, the technologies proposed and other details.

Comment Submission

  • ** provide a link to a public comment form (Google forms are recommended for ease of data capture) - see example: Public comment form.jpg
  • Select the document you are commenting on from the appropriate form
  • Provide your name and email address
  • Add the Profile section and line number (if applicable) to which your comment refers
  • Describe the issue and your propose a resolution
  • When you have entered each of your comments, you may submit the form
  • e-mail Profile Authoring Group with general comments about the Profile/Protocol concept, structure, process, etc.

The QIBA Biomarker Committees consider all comments submitted, and where appropriate, post responses.

Public Comment Documents

see http://qibawiki.rsna.org/index.php/Profiles