Committee Procedures

From QIBA Wiki
Revision as of 19:17, 5 February 2019 by Kevino (Talk | contribs) (Email Ballot: per CP-SC-003)

Jump to: navigation, search

Meeting Procedures

The goal is group consensus and the input and endorsement of imaging community stakeholders on major decisions.

A record of committee decisions and rationale is necessary to be effective and learn.

  • Secretariat (RSNA) records minutes (call summaries) for committee meetings
  • Secretariat maintains rosters for each committee indicating which members currently have Voting Privileges
    • Members who believe their attendance record is in error should contact the secretariat, preferably before the meeting


Procedural decisions (such as whether to send a document to ballot) are voted on during meetings

  • Chairs accept motions, seconds, discussion, and then call for a vote (see Roberts Rules if you need to get more elaborate)
  • Members who have Voting Privileges count towards quorum and may vote
  • Chairs resolve negative votes and large numbers of abstentions per the consensus process
    • details of the resolution discussion in the minutes is desirable
  • Secretariat records the motion, tally of those against/abstaining/in-favor, and the details of negative votes in the minutes

Email Ballot

Some decisions are put to ballot. This allows more deliberation on the subject material than a vote in committee.

  • Chairs submit the ballot question and length of the ballot period to the Secretariat
    • The ballot period may be specified by the particular procedure that calls for a ballot
    • It is generally not less than 14 days to allow for members away on vacation
    • If reviewing lengthy documents or collecting feedback within member organizations is involved 30 days or more is better
  • Secretariat emails the ballot to all members with Voting Privileges on the committee making the decision
  • Secretariat emails a notification of ineligibility to the rest of the members of the committee making the decision
    • Members who do not have Voting Privileges will thus be aware of the ballot and are still permitted to submit comments
    • Members who believe their attendance record is in error can review of their attendance with the secretariat and if they are found to be eligible will be sent a ballot
  • Secretariat compiles the ballot responses and comments for the Chairs
  • Chairs ratify the resulting tally in the next committee meeting
    • this includes resolving negative votes and large numbers of abstentions per the consensus process
  • Secretariat records resolution results/rationale in the minutes

Consensus Process

As a group setting standards on behalf of a community, QIBA Committees actively pursue Consensus.

  • strictly speaking a vote/ballot can pass with a quorum of votes and a majority in favor, BUT
    • a negative vote results in further discussion
      • understand the reason for each negative vote and attempt to find a compromise or resolution that often allows everyone to vote in favor
      • if after due diligence exploring compromises it is not possible, the chairs can accept the majority finding and the negative voters have had a chance to have their say and register their issues into the minutes
    • a large number of abstentions also warrants discussion; it can indicate many people have:
      • misgivings
      • not been able to adequately evaluate the question

Committee Leadership

  • Coordinating Committees, Biomarker Committees and Task Forces are encouraged to have 2 or 3 leaders who are preferably drawn from diverse backgrounds (Researchers, Clinicians, Physicists, Vendors, Regulators, etc.)
    • If not possible, committees are permitted to have some concentration but should discuss plans to expand stakeholder representation at least annually

See Also